People
Pastor William Buettner (1871–1874)
William Buettner served as Saint Luke’s second pastor from 1871 to 1874, when he was abruptly asked to resign. We know little about him. The congregation was anxious to fill the vacancy left by William Drees’ resignation, so when the first candidate declined the call, they quickly turned to Buettner in July 1871.
Initially Buettner made an excellent impression. He was a good speaker, able to attract people to the church. Yet, soon after he arrived, some quietly raised concerns about the way he conducted his office. These eventually became public, along with concerns about his lifestyle. Following an investigation, on July 6, 1874 the council met, adjourned temporarily so they could discuss the issue off the record, and reconvened to ask for his resignation. Buettner resigned the next day.
We know nothing about the specific charges against him. The fiftieth anniversary history of Saint Luke’s states only that he lived in “grievous sins” for a long time.
Pastor Wilhelm Busse (1874 – 1899)

Wilhelm Busse served Saint Luke’s at its height. He championed the increased use of English and led the move to make the congregation an independent body.
Educated at the University of Göttingen and the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia, Busse served as pastor of a Lutheran congregation in Poughkeepsie, NY, before being called to Saint Luke’s in 1874. He came at a hopeful time in the congregation’s history; his predecessor, William Buettner, had been asked to resign after only three years. The congregation was so happy to welcome Busse that they paid his rent and furnished his home at their expense.
During Busse’s ministry, Saint Luke’s grew dramatically. The year after his arrival, the congregation moved to a former Presbyterian church on W. 42nd Street that could seat 1,500. At its height St. Luke’s had some 3,000 members, a Sunday School of more than 800 children, and confirmation classes of more than 150 young people. It was not unusual for Busse to conduct 100 weddings a month.
Busse’s most significant contribution to Saint Luke’s was leading it to independence. Shortly after he arrived, the Lutheran Ministerium of New York, which the congregation had joined in 1853, sought to impose restrictions that some perceived as limiting the power of the individual congregations. Busse vehemently opposed these measures, arguing that the only authority for congregations was the Word of God. The congregation supported his stance and declared themselves independent in 1880. Busse joined the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod soon after. Yet, although they liberally supported Missouri institutions and called their pastors from the Synod, Saint Luke’s remained independent until it joined the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in 1989.
Busse was a strong advocate for expanding the use of English in an effort to keep the second generation close to the church. In 1894 he convinced the congregation to experiment with an English Sunday evening worship service. It generated an extraordinary amount of interest, and for a short time there was a discussion of calling an assistant since Busse could not preach in English. Nevertheless, the experiment ultimately failed. Dissent grew and came to a head at a congregational meeting in 1895, when the members agreed to cancel the English services for the sake of peace.
In October 1899, Saint Luke’s held an elaborate 25th anniversary celebration for their much beloved pastor. Sadly, Busse died of a sudden heart attack the following month. The congregation continued to show their love for him for many years thereafter by caring for his gravesite at the Lutheran Cemetery (now All Faiths) in Queens.
John Danielson

John Danielson’s generosity to Saint Luke’s spanned more than five decades. He served on the council for many years and chaired it from 1991 until 2001. Wherever he saw a need—large or small—he stepped forward to address it. He played the organ for the 50th anniversary of the church building, volunteered for the soup kitchen, and helped clean and decorate the church for each holiday. In 1973, Danielson helped found Project FIND, the first senior citizens’ center in the area. He led the redesign of the lounge in the 1990s and served on the call committee that brought Pastors Schmiege and Strasser to the congregation. A long-time choir member, he also devoted more than a year to organizing and cataloging some 1,200 pieces of music in the congregation’s collection.
Danielson was especially proud of chairing the committee that selected the current Walcker organ, even traveling to Europe to hear one of the company’s instruments before making the final decision.
Pastor William Drees (1850 – 1870)

William Drees was the founder of Saint Luke’s and their pastor for the first 20 years. Under his direction, the church grew from a tiny, struggling group to a large, established congregation serving not only the religious but also the social and educational needs of a growing immigrant community.
Drees emigrated to the United States in 1846 with the intention of serving Lutherans in the Midwest. But when he landed in New York City, Reformed ministers convinced him to lead a tiny mission on Manhattan’s West Side. The congregation grappled with financial difficulties, indifference, and internal dissent, problems laid at Drees’ feet. In the spring of 1850, the church council asked him to resign. He refused and, in a dramatic confrontation, on Aug. 4, 1850 was forcibly removed from the Sunday service. On September 1, 1850, he and his followers founded Saint Luke’s as a Reformed church. Drees, who was confessionally Lutheran, became a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Ministerium in 1852; the congregation joined the following year.
Saint Luke’s, whose members were primarily truck farmers and artisans, struggled financially during the early years, with Drees relying on Sunday offerings (the first of which garnered 11 cents) and the generosity of individual members for his living. Nevertheless, he had ambitious plans for the small congregation. He quickly established a Sunday School and a parochial school, and realizing its importance for the future of the congregation, introduced English in both. Under his guidance, the congregation transitioned from worshiping in rental spaces to the purchase of their first permanent church building in 1863. In order to enhance worship, he organized the first choir. Gradually the congregation grew, with numbers exploding following the resumption of immigration following the Civil War.
Since St. Luke’s founding, Drees had held both ecclesial and temporal leadership, serving as pastor and as chairman of the congregation. In 1870, however, fearing that with the enormous growth of the congregation one man could no longer handle both offices, the congregation adopted a constitution separating the two. Drees took offense at what he considered a slight to his efficiency and abruptly resigned.
Deaconess Martha Eber (1957 – 1976)

Martha Eber served as deaconess from 1957 to 1976, when Hell’s Kitchen had become one of the most dangerous neighborhoods in New York City. As residents fled rising crime and deteriorating housing, they left behind immigrants and the elderly poor living is SROs. In this environment, Eber acted as a social case manager for the neighborhood, filling in the gaps left by other social agencies and ensuring that Saint Luke’s funds and activities were coordinated with community services and resources.
In 1975, Sister Martha was seriously injured in a mugging. Fearing for her safety, the congregation urged her to retire, which she did in the spring of 1976. But she was back the next day as a volunteer. She worked at Saint Luke’s until two weeks before her death in 1991 at age 91. For her work in the community, she was known as The Angel of 46th Street.
Pastor Dale Hanson (1975 – 2000)

Dale Hansen led Saint Luke’s during the most difficult years in its history. Under his direction, the tiny congregation became a powerful presence in the community and a forceful advocate for neighborhood’s revitalization. During his tenure, Saint Luke’s established its Soup Kitchen, its signature ministry.
Hansen came to Saint Luke’s following years of ministry in the Midwest as a dean of students at Concordia, Seward, and as dean and public relations director for the North Wisconsin District of the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. Prior to joining Saint Luke’s, he was senior pastor of Zion Lutheran Church, an affluent, 3,000-member congregation in Wausau, Wisconsin.
Hansen once explained that he could have stayed at Zion in a “push-button ministry,” but that he believed strongly that God had called him to minister on the “front lines.” He came at a time when Hell’s Kitchen and Saint Luke’s were at their lowest. Violence, prostitution, and drug dealing had invaded the area; the neighborhood was considered one of the most dangerous in the city. Hansen was stabbed twice while helping people who had appeared at the church. Many fled, leaving behind Hispanic immigrants and the elderly poor. Saint Luke’s membership declined dramatically. Only a tiny, dedicated core remained to carry out the congregation’s ministry.
Despite the challenges, Hansen extended Saint Luke’s neighborhood outreach begun under Pastor Albert Neibacher. He expanded the Spanish ministry and in 1977 opened the congregation’s Soup Kitchen. As leader of the Restaurant Row Association, he was a driving force in the revitalization of 46th Street.
A master of public relations, Hanson used his skills to draw attention to the needs of the neighborhood and to gain national and international recognition and support for the congregation’s ministry. He traveled widely, using his many contacts to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars for Saint Luke’s mission.
Feeling that his “steam was beginning to wane” after 25 years at Saint Luke’s and that a younger and more energetic leadership was needed for the parish, he retired in 2000.
Pastor William Koepchen (1900 – 1936)

William Koepchen served as pastor of Saint Luke’s for over 35 years. During his ministry, he widened the congregation’s focus to encompass Lutheran institutions and oversaw the building of the 46th St. church.
Born in Chicago in 1864, Koepchen was raised in a Lutheran orphanage, an experience that gained him a lasting interest in the church’s social institutions. He graduated from Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, in 1888 and ministered to congregations in New England before coming to Saint Luke’s in 1900.
Koepchen served Saint Luke’s during a period of dramatic change. As second-generation congregants left Hell’s Kitchen in large numbers and the Depression later pushed many out of the city, Saint Luke’s transitioned from a large neighborhood congregation to a smaller, widely scattered one. Thus, Koepchen’s major challenge was ministering to his far-flung flock while maintaining his small core. In an effort to encourage young people to stay, he promoted the greater use of English in services and expanded congregational programs for youth. Koepchen is best remembered for guiding the congregation’s move to its present home on 46th Street, the first church the congregation built in its long history.
Pastor Koepchen was a prominent member of the greater Lutheran community, extremely active in institution building on the local and national levels. During his ministry, Saint Luke’s became deeply involved in supporting such Lutheran social welfare organizations as Bethlehem Orphanage, the Lutheran Home for the Elderly, and the Lutheran Hospital. He was a major force in the development of Concordia College, Bronxville, personally raising large sums of money and directing the planning of its campus.
Koepchen also began Saint Luke’s outreach to the Lutheran acting community, officiating at weddings and funerals and giving help to the needy. At his death in 1936, he was known as the Protestant Bishop of Times Square.
Pastor Albert L. Neibacher (1936 – 1975)

Albert Neibacher served Saint Luke’s for over 39 years. During his tenure, the congregation expanded its mission to include community affairs, reaching out to Hell’s Kitchen not only to save souls but also to address the complex material and social needs of the increasingly diverse neighborhood. In so doing, Saint Luke’s became a pioneer in modern urban ministry.
Neibacher came to Saint Luke’s in 1935 as an assistant to Pastor William Koepchen. Not yet ordained, he worked as a youth minister and oversaw neighborhood evangelization. When Pastor Koepchen died suddenly the following year, the congregation, impressed with the very young Neibacher, called him as pastor. At 26, he was the youngest pastor in Manhattan.
Neibacher attacked his new position with enthusiasm, working to strengthen church organizations and extend the congregation’s outreach to Hell’s Kitchen. Under his leadership the choir was revived, and teens and young people’s societies established. The congregation opened its extensive facilities to neighborhood youth and established the Dorcas Guild, the women’s group whose mission was to help the needy in the area.
During World War II, Saint Luke’s was the site of the Lutheran Service Center for the East Coast. Here, under Neibacher’s leadership, the congregation developed an extensive program for service members designed to recreate the normal church life they had just left back home. Over the course of the war, Saint Luke’s welcomed some 5,500 military personnel regardless of race or religion.
In the post-war years, Pastor Neibacher expanded Saint Luke’s outreach. Announcing that the future of the Hell’s Kitchen was the future of Saint Luke’s, he oversaw the development of extensive social programs with an emphasis on housing, youth, education, anti-poverty, and community revitalization.
As the neighborhood declined dramatically in the 1960s and 1970s, the efforts to address community problems took a tremendous toll on the pastor, which he openly shared with his congregants. Some outsiders urged relocating Saint Luke’s or moving Neibacher’s residence from the increasingly dangerous neighborhood.
But Neibacher stayed, providing leadership and a witness to the church’s commitment in the area. He retired in 1974.
Laura D. Neibacher

Laura Dahlen left college at 19 to marry Albert Neibacher in 1937. Her wealthy parents were not pleased. She admitted that moving from suburban New Jersey to Hell’s Kitchen in the middle of the Depression was challenging. Nevertheless, she flourished. She was extremely active in the congregation – the Ladies Aid Society loved her fun-loving spirit – and was engaged in the youth programs Pastor Neibacher established to reach out to the neighborhood. She was his informal assistant and buffer, handling minor, time-consuming matters to free him for more important concerns. Pastor Neibacher publicly described her as his “fellow laborer” and “partner in ministry,” and routinely thanked her in his annual reports.
Perhaps Laura Neibacher’s most important contribution was as a witness. As Hell’s Kitchen became more blighted and dangerous, many fled, but the Neibachers stayed, a testimony to their commitment to the congregation and the neighborhood.
Genevieve Savio

During World War II, Genevieve Savio hosted the Lutheran Service Center for the East Coast, implementing Saint Luke’s ambitious program of recreating a sense of the normal church life that service members had left back home. The 20-something Savio coordinated the effort, planning excursions, hosting dinners, and raising funds. Ultimately, the Center served some 5,500 military personnel. It is thanks to Savio’s meticulous record-keeping that Saint Luke’s has a detailed archive of this valuable mission.
Savio remained deeply involved at Saint Luke’s for more than six decades. She was ubiquitous, serving on numerous committees – the Altar Guild, the Worship and Spiritual Life committees, even on a temporary committee to investigate boiler problems – and was active in the soup kitchen. She taught Sunday School for many years before becoming its superintendent. Savio was among the 25 women invited to become voting members following Saint Luke’s adoption of women’s suffrage in 1970. She was also one of the four to be elected to office that year. In the ensuing years she served as a deacon and a trustee, and was secretary for over a decade.
J. Louis Schaefer

J. Louis Schaefer spearheaded Saint Luke’s move to the 46th Street. A wealthy banker who served as the congregation’s president from 1913 until his sudden death in 1927, he was the individual the congregation looked to for financial advice and support. He routinely provided the annual bond required of the treasurer, paid for building repairs and improvements, and matched funds for the congregation’s charity campaigns. Saint Luke’s did not rely on lending institutions for short-term loans. Instead, they borrowed from a few wealthy members, primarily Schaefer, who always returned the interest.
When the congregation determined it had to move from 42nd Street, Schaefer directed the effort. He recommended they remain in the Hell’s Kitchen, even outlining the most desirable blocks, and searched for a property. When a suitable site became available, he personally bought the land (for today’s equivalent of $2 million), holding it until the congregation could sell the 42nd Street building. He negotiated the sale of the old building and then closely supervised the construction of the new church. Schaefer and his wife, Susan K. Schaefer, generously funded furnishing for the building, donating the altar and pulpit. For his efforts, he was given the honor of laying the cornerstone (click here to see the Cornerstone Contents). The ceremonial hammer and trowel he used are now housed in Saint Luke’s archives.
Susan Karsch Schaefer

Susan Karsch came from a family who held leadership positions at Saint Luke’s for generations. As president of the congregation, her grandfather led the move to the 42nd St. church in 1875. Her father served as council member for many years. An early graduate of Hunter College, Kasch married J. Louis Schaefer in 1896. The wealthy couple were deeply involved in Saint Luke’s, giving generously of their time and resources throughout their lives.
Schaefer headed the Ladies Aid Society for more than 25 years, during which the organization was the dominant social and fund-raising arm of the congregation. Following her husband’s death in 1927, she became a major benefactor, routinely thanked in the annual congregational meeting for her generosity.
Schaefer was particularly interested in the music program. She sponsored the music for special services and funded the section soloists and organist for several years. But her generosity was far reaching – donating everything from curtain fabric to the complete renovation of the kitchen. Her offerings and those of her sons helped keep the congregation afloat during the difficult years of the Depression.
As a woman, Schaefer had no official voice, a situation that clearly irked her. At the 1931 congregational meeting, she publicly asked that women be given the suffrage. Her motion was referred to the church council, who voted to give women voice, but not vote. She never lived to see Saint Luke’s adopt women suffrage, but her son, Bernard Schaefer, implemented the measure in 1970.

